
A Wisconsin prosecutor said the officer’s deadly force was “reasonable,” but the family says the videos show an execution—two sharply different stories now define Corey Ruiz’s death.
Story Snapshot
- Dane County’s prosecutor declined charges, citing knife threat and failed Tasers.
- State investigators said Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson fired the shots that killed Ruiz.
- Family attorney Ben Crump calls the shooting an “execution” based on video shown to them.
- Gaps remain on key facts like Taser timing, injury details, and exact shot count.
What The Prosecutor Decided And Why It Matters
On November 19, 2026, Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne declined to charge Madison Police Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson in the fatal shooting of Corey Ruiz. Ozanne wrote that deadly force was reasonable because Ruiz resisted officers, produced a knife, and was not stopped by multiple Taser attempts. The office said it reviewed reports, diagrams, and videos from squads, surveillance cameras, and citizens before reaching the decision, signaling reliance on a broad record beyond one viral clip.
The Wisconsin Department of Justice led the outside investigation, as state law requires for police-involved deaths. The agency confirmed Baitinger-Peterson fired and struck Ruiz during the encounter. That structure aims to reduce conflicts of interest and to separate the evidence-gathering from charging choices, which remain with the local prosecutor. The approach can boost trust for some readers, yet it still leaves room for doubt if the public cannot see the full files.
What The Videos Show—and What We Still Do Not Know
News accounts say officers struggled with Ruiz, reported a knife in play, used Tasers that did not stop him, and then Baitinger-Peterson fired at close range. Madison’s police chief said one officer showed hand slash marks consistent with a knife, but he did not identify which officer, and officials did not detail the injuries. Reports conflict on whether two or three shots were fired, creating a basic factual gap that officials have not resolved in public summaries.
The prosecutor referenced multiple video sources. Yet key facts are still missing for outside review. Public accounts do not specify the Taser models, whether probes hit, or the time from the last Taser use to the shots. They also do not provide a clear, public record of where the knife was in the crucial second before each shot. Those details matter because they bear on whether an imminent threat existed under the law.
How The Family And Community Are Responding
Attorney Ben Crump, who represents the Ruiz family, rejects the prosecutor’s call. He says video shows officers tackle, tase, and kick Ruiz, then shoot him on the ground at close range, including in the face, which he calls an execution and excessive force. He argues nothing on the videos justifies the killing and calls for criminal charges. Protests and vigils followed the decision, adding pressure for a fuller public release of the evidence.
NEW PODCAST: No charges in the police shooting of Corey Ruiz. Rob and Stephanie break down how the DA’s decision came out, what the newly released investigative file shows, and where the oversight fight stands. Plus: mayoral candidate Syed Abbas. https://t.co/QrgCZf0TFe
— Madison365 (@madison_365) November 20, 2026
The family has sought an independent autopsy and wants a transparent review. That echoes a wider national concern shared by many across the political spectrum. People see leaders and systems that guard their own, whether in policing or elsewhere. Releasing the complete investigative file and the full charging memo would help rebuild trust. It would also clarify the number of shots, the Taser performance, the injury claims, and the knife’s position at each moment.
What Accountability Still Looks Like After No Charges
A no-charge decision answers only one question: criminal liability. It does not decide whether officer tactics met policy, whether training worked, or whether another approach could have avoided gunfire. Department reviews and city oversight can still examine those issues. State investigators and the district attorney cited many videos and reports, but without broad disclosure, many citizens will keep assuming the worst from institutions they already distrust.
Sources:
jsonline.com, wsaw.com, clickondetroit.com, captimes.com, adn.com, abcnews4.com, news8000.com, madison.com












