The New York Times has often hired columnists they label as “conservatives” to provide a semblance of balance, but these writers typically hail from elite backgrounds and lack grassroots connections. One such columnist, Bret Stephens, recently penned an op-ed titled “Republicans Will Regret a Second Trump Term,” which sparked significant attention.
Stephens, who has an extensive academic background and has likely never experienced everyday American life, argues that the GOP will face three major regrets if Trump is reelected. First, he claims Trump’s victory will “re-energize and radicalize” the left, suggesting it’s Trump’s fault for the extreme reactions during the George Floyd protests. Stephens believes a Trump win will lead to heightened leftist activity.
Second, Stephens predicts Trump will be a “down-ballot loser,” causing government division and paralysis. However, many argue that the government is already in a state of gridlock, making this point moot.
Lastly, Stephens asserts that Trump will appoint extreme loyalists in his second term, leading to undesirable outcomes for traditional Republicans. He fears these appointments will push policies far beyond what old-school Republicans expect.
Stephens’ perspective seems out of touch with the realities faced by many Americans. For example, his assertion that the Biden years have been “mostly free” of leftist extremism overlooks significant incidents like the anti-Semitic riots in Los Angeles. These events are not mere exceptions but signs of a deeper issue.
The op-ed was published just before the assassination attempt on Trump, making Stephens’ warnings appear prescient. Since the attempt, media narratives have quickly shifted to blame Trump for various societal issues, showing the bias that Stephens’ column echoed.
Stephens’ views reflect the detachment of coastal elites from everyday Republican voters. Many conservatives believe that the mainstream media and establishment figures will continue to oppose any Republican who threatens the status quo, regardless of whether it’s Trump or another candidate.
